Menus (New) | BitesByBetsy

BITESBYBETSY SPOTLIGHT OF THE MONTH!

These are spotlight dessert dishes of the current month.

Holiday Pack # 1

This pack includes 12 (Three 3x3 bars of each flavor) of your favorite Cheesecake Bars of 2025! Caramel Apple Pie, Brownie Turtle, Blackberry Swirl, and Snickerdoodle! Something scrumptious for everyone!

$40

Holiday Pack # 2

Includes 12 (three 3x3 bars of each flavor) of your favorite Gooey Butter cheesecake bars! Original, Snickerdoodle, Chocolate, and Red Velvet! This pack is perfect for all of your Holiday guests, especially those who have never had this STL classic!

$40

Holiday Pack # 3

Includes the same delicious flavors but in a cookie form! We have Original, Snickerdoodle, Chocolate, and Red Velvet. Each pack contains 16 cookies (4 of each flavor)

$25

Holiday Pack # 4

We have a combo pack of two of your favorite Christmas flavors! This pack includes 6 (3x3 cheesecake bars) of both Mint Chip and Brownie Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecakes! Traditional and so decadent!

$40

COMBO PACKS

How about a combo or sample pack?

Dozen Combo Pack

A combo pack contains 6 of any two items - $40 per combo pack

$40

6 bars of any 2 flavors

Banana Nut Cheesecake Bars

Pecan Pie Cheesecake Bar

Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Cheesecake Bar

SAMPLER PACK

How about a combo or sample pack? Sampler pack includes 6 different items (a total of 24 bars). If you prefer, the bars can be cut into bite size pieces. $78 per sampler pack.

Sample Pack

Sample pack includes 6 different items (total of 24 bars). $78 per sampler pack.

$78

Any 6 items (24 bars total)

Banana Nut Cheesecake Bars

Pecan Pie Cheesecake Bar

Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Cheesecake Bar

CHEESECAKE BARS

Mint Chip Cheesecake Bar

With this classic combo, you get every part of the mint chip flavor. It delivers it in almost these three perfect sections. First comes the mint chip cheesecake, then you’re hit with the chocolate, and last, you get that nice mint Oreo cookie crust. $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Chocolate Peppermint cheesecake bar

The Perfect Christmas dessert for all you chocolate and peppermint lovers. We start with a fudgy brownie mixed with peppermint candy pieces. We add a decadent chocolate cheesecake and more peppermint candy pieces. Fabulous! $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Blackberry Swirl Cheesecake Bars

We start with a combination of graham cracker and vanilla wafer crust topped with our silky, creamy cheesecake! We then swirl our tart, juicy blackberries into the cheesecake and bake to a golden brown! $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Banana Nut Cheesecake Bars

These bars are close to my heart. I found my mom's recipe box which contained our family's favorite banana nut bread. I put my own twist on the recipe to create this decadent cheesecake bar. $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Pecan Pie Cheesecake Bar

The layers on these Pecan Pie Cheesecake Bars are incredible! One tasty bite and you'll fall in love! From the graham cracker and pecan crust to the sweet cheesecake filling and the delicious, gooey pecan topping, this holiday dessert receives rave reviews from everyone! $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Cheesecake Bar

A buttery vanilla and cinnamon sugar crust holds yummy pumpkin cheesecake topped with more snickerdoodle goodness! $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Smore’s Cheesecake Bars

You do not even have to build a campfire to enjoy these decadent desserts! We take an ooey gooey graham cracker crust loaded with marshmallows and chocolate, cover it with our smooth delicious cheesecake and then top it all off with more ooey gooey chocolate and toasted marshmallows!! YUM!!! $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecake

A crave-worthy combination of two amazing desserts, this Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecake combines juicy baked pineapple in a brown sugar topping with a decadent cheesecake base. Gluten free available $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Strawberry Cheesecake Bars

These cheesecake bars have a blast of strawberry freshness swirled into the bars. They are a perfect combination of tart and sweet! Also available gluten free! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Key Lime Cheesecake Bars

Do you love cheesecake and key lime pie? The tanginess of the key lime with the creamy decadent cheesecake is so awesome you will feel like you are hanging out on the beaches of Key West! Available gluten free $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Gooey Butter Bars

A Saint Louis classic! Flavors: Chocolate Gooey Butter: Ooey Gooey Chocolate decadence Snickerdoodle Gooey Butter: Cinnamon sugar is the star of this Gooey Butter Bar Pumpkin Gooey Butter: Our traditional gooey butter with a pumpkin pie twist Gluten Free Available $40 / Dozen

Original

$40

Chocolate Gooey Butter

$40

Snickerdoodle Gooey Butter

$40

Pumpkin Gooey Butter

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Bars

These Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Bars are an Oreo lover's heaven! We start with an oreo crust and top with silky smooth cheesecake baked with crushed Oreos. Finally, we top it off with an Oreo cookie! Perfect summer treat! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Reece’s Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

This creamy, rich, and indulgent Reese’s cheesecake tastes like a giant peanut butter cup and is the perfect dessert for any cheesecake lover. Gluten-Free available $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Blackberry Cobbler Cheesecake Bars

Celebrate summer with tart, juicy blackberries nestled in a golden brown cobbler topped with silky, creamy cheesecake and more crumbly cobbler goodness! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Apple Pie Cheesecake with Caramel Bars

BitesbyBetsy had to put our own twist on this classic dessert by creating an Apple Pie Cheesecake with Caramel Bar. We take a buttery shortbread crust, our traditional delicious cheesecake, ooey gooey apples, cinnamon streusel topping, and spin it into this decadent dessert! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Turtle Brownie Cheesecake Bars

The best of both worlds - a fudgy brownie bottom topped with a creamy cheesecake layer. And if that wasn't already delicious enough, there is a layer of chocolate, caramel and pecans! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Chocolate Toffee cheesecake bars

These melt in your mouth treats are absolutely delicious. We start with a brownie crust and top with our creamy cheesecake mixed with heath bar pieces. Just to make it more decadent, we also top the bars with more heath bar pieces. $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Salted Caramel Cheesecake Bars

Salted caramel is all the craze! These bars deliver both the velvety cheesecake and rich salted caramel on top of a salted pretzel crust! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Triple Chocolate Cheesecake Bars

Chocolate, Chocolate, Chocolate! Decadent treat with a fudgy chocolate crust, chocolate cheesecake and white chocolate topping! A yummy must! $40 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Snickerdoodle Cheesecake Bars

A buttery vanilla and cinnamon sugar crust holds yummy cheesecake topped with more snickerdoodle goodness! $40 / Dozen

$40

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Keto Cheesecake Bars

Think the keto diet means you can't have cheesecake? Think again. Our keto-friendly cheesecake is made with almond flour, Swerve and Monkfruit then topped with fresh berries! Delicious! $42 / Dozen

$40

Gluten free

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

CHEESECAKES

Classic Cheesecake

Our original classic cheesecake topped with fresh strawberries. Also available gluten-free! (Whole Cheesecake)

Original with Strawberries - a blast of

$42

Turtle – Oreo crust with our delicious c

$42

Salted Caramel – Graham cracker and pret

$42

Reece’s Peanut Butter Cup – Oreo crust t

$42

S'mores - A campfire classic in a cheese

$42

Gluten free

Gluten-Free

Gluten-Free$8

4" Cheesecake Flight

Our classic cheesecake is one of the most scrumptious and honestly is the BEST cheesecake you will ever have! The recipe started in Sicily and was passed down many generations! These 4" cheesecakes are the same luscious creamy and decadent cheesecake! Perfect for everyone for all occasions! Choose from our flavors or get one of each! **Please select your choices: $10 for each / minimum of 2:

Flavor Selection

Original with Strawberries - a blast of $10

Banana Cream – Vanilla wafter crust with$10

Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Bars

Bourbon Bacon Cheesecake

We have constructed the perfect blend of top shelf bourbon with our original decadent cheesecake. Top that with very ooey gooey candied bacon. This has become a huge fan favorite for any bourbon lover! The cost is $55 and it is available gluten-free!

$55

Gluten free

Gluten-Free

Gluten-Free$8

COOKIES & CANDY

Gooey Butter Cookies

St. Louis classic in a BIG 4” cookie! Gooey and delicious! Available in multiple favors! $25 per dozen.

$25

Gooey Butter Cookie Flavors

Original

Chocolate

Snickerdoodle

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Sandwich Cookies

These BIG 4” sandwich cookies have a layer of our classic, creamy, delicious cheesecake in the middle! Everyone will go crazy for these amazing cookie treats! Place them in the freezer for a scrumptious frozen treat! $30 per dozen (24 individual cookies)

$30

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Sandwich Cookies

Fudgy German Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

If you are a fan of German Chocolate cake, these cookies are for you! Ooey, gooey caramel pecan filling sandwiched between two German chocolate cake cookies. (A Dozen)

$25

Carrot Cake Sandwich Cookies

Classic carrot cake taste but even better! Soft, delicious cookie with oats, carrots and walnuts sandwiched together with a soft scrumptious cream cheese filling. Simply mouth-watering!! (A Dozen)

$25

Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars

If you love Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, you will LOVE these bars! Also available gluten-free! (A Dozen)

$30

Bar Size

12 bars = 3x3

24 bars = 1½ x 3

48 bars = 1½ x 1½$5

Twix bars

The combination of chocolate, caramel and biscuit serves as the perfect mix of creaminess, sweetness and crunch!

$30